万物简史 第71期:敲石头的人们(3)

Among the questions that attracted interest in thatfanatically inquisitive age was one that hadpuzzled people for a very long time—namely, whyancient clamshells and other marine fossils were sooften found on mountaintops. How on earth did theyget there?

在那个爱好钻研的时代，在许多令人感兴趣的问题当中，有个问题长期以来困扰着人们--即山顶上为什么经常发现古代的蛤蜊壳和别的海生物化石。它们到底是怎么到那里的?

Those who thought they had a solution fell into twoopposing camps. One group, known as the Neptunists, was convinced that everything onEarth, including seashells in improbably lofty places, could be explained by rising and fallingsea levels. They believed that mountains, hills, and other features were as old as the Earthitself, and were changed only when water sloshed over them during periods of global flooding.

许多人认为自己已经找到答案。他们分为两个对立的阵营。水成论者认为，地球上的一切，包括在高处的海洋贝壳，可以用海平面的升高和降低来解释。他们认为，山脉、丘陵和其他地貌与地球本身一样古老，只是在全球洪水时期被水冲刷的过程中发生了一些变化。

Opposing them were the Plutonists, who noted that volcanoes and earthquakes, among otherenlivening agents, continually changed the face of the planet but clearly owed nothing towayward seas. The Plutonists also raised awkward questions about where all the water wentwhen it wasn't in flood. If there was enough of it at times to cover the Alps, then where, pray,was it during times of tranquility, such as now? Their belief was that the Earth was subject toprofound internal forces as well as surface ones. However, they couldn't convincingly explainhow all those clamshells got up there.

对立面是火成论者。他们认为有许多充满活力的动因，其中，火山和地震不断改变这颗行星的表面，但显然跟遥远的大海毫无关系。火成论者还提出难以回答的问题：不发洪水的时候，这水都流到哪里去了?要是有时候存在足以淹没阿尔卑斯山的水，那么请问，在平静下来以后，比如现在，这水都流到哪里去了?他们认为，地球受到内部深处的力和表面的力的作用。然而，他们无法令人信服地解释，蛤蜊的壳是怎么跑到山顶上去的。